James is a solicitor acting for a contractor in a dispute concerning alleged defective construction work on a commercial property. The claim is for £75,000 and is proceeding on the fast track. James is in the process of preparing standard disclosure for his client. During a review of his client's emails, James discovers an email sent by his client three months after the alleged defects arose. In the email, the client states that the work was actually completed to a satisfactory standard and that they have no complaints about the contractor's performance. This email directly contradicts the client's position in the proceedings, as the claimant is now alleging that the work was defective. James discusses the email with his client, who insists that it should not be disclosed to the other side as it would significantly harm their case.
Question 1 of 20